| Tom Grillo |
2011 |
INF |
Florida Gulf Coast University |
| Nick Battas |
2011 |
P |
Adelphi University |
| Spencer Bilello |
2011 |
1B/P |
Adelphi University |
| Nick Girardi |
2011 |
OF |
Manhattan College |
| Steven Goldstein |
2011 |
OF |
Stony Brook University |
| Vinny Orlando |
2011 |
INF |
Mercy College |
| Lou Lambros |
2011 |
C |
Iona College |
| Yonah Perline |
2011 |
P |
Farleigh Dickenson University |
| Brandon Lubrano |
2011 |
P/1B |
Mout St. Mary's |
| Robert Galligan |
2011 |
P |
University of Maryland |
| Derek Hirsch |
2010 |
OF |
St. Thomas Acquinas College |
| Chris Dragone |
2010 |
P |
Farmingdale University |
| Brandon Stahl |
2010 |
SS |
Old Dominion University |
| Harry Stange |
2010 |
P |
Adelphi University |
| Kyle Hansen |
2009 |
P |
St. John's University (2009 NYSSWA Co-Player of the Year) |
| John Yohe |
2009 |
P |
Bentley College |
| Juan Borbon |
2009 |
IF |
Molloy College |
| Justin Jorgensen |
2008 |
P |
Molloy College (2008 NSCHSAA Pitcher of the Year) |
| Dan Lackner |
2008 |
OF |
New York Institute of Technology (2008 NSCHSAA Player of the Year) |
| Gabby Lebron |
2008 |
IF |
Guilford College |
| Conor Burke |
2007 |
IF |
Suffolk Community College |
| T.J. Thomas |
2007 |
1B/OF |
San Diego State/Hofstra University |
| Mike Rocco |
2007 |
IF |
Briarcliff College |
| Kevin Egan |
2007 |
P |
Embry-Riddle University |
| Jose Lebron |
2006 |
IF |
Bloomfield College |
| Anthony Orsano |
2006 |
C/OF |
Marshall University/Suffolk CC/SUNY Old Westbury |
| Joe Van Meter |
2006 |
IF/P |
Arizona State/Virginia Commonwealth |
| Julian Medina |
2005 |
IF |
University of South Florida |
| James Niesuchouski |
2005 |
P |
DeSales University/Lamar University |
| Phil Pursino |
2005 |
C |
St. Joseph's University (PA) |
| George Statler |
2005 |
IF |
Adelphi University |
| Joey Maca |
2004 |
IF |
Catholic University |
| Max Most |
2004 |
OF |
Marist College/Old Dominion University |
| Chris Murphy |
2004 |
IF |
LeMoyne College |
| Brandon Pick |
2004 |
P |
Brandeis College |
| Ed Shapiro |
2004 |
1B |
Seton Hall University |
| Sean Sorise |
2004 |
P |
Fairfield University/SUNY Stony Brook |
| Chris Tipa |
2004 |
1B |
C.W. Post/University of New Haven |
| Nick Capowski |
2003 |
OF |
Marietta College/Iona College |
| Jeff Denlea |
2003 |
P |
Hofstra University |
| Matthew DeRosa |
2003 |
P |
St. Thomas Acquinas College |
| Jimmy Basnight |
2002 |
OF |
St. Bonaventure/SUNY Cortland |
| Rich Bianculli |
2002 |
C |
University of Delaware/Nassau Community College |
| Peter Petrides |
2002 |
C/OF |
Queensboro Community College/SUNY Old Westbury |
| Ricky Piovesan |
2002 |
IF |
Pace University/SUNY Cortland |
| James Rogers |
2002 |
C |
SUNY Old Westbury |
| Matt Schram |
2002 |
1B |
SUNY Old Westbury |
| McClain Tini |
2001 |
P |
Catholic University |
| Jason Nolasco |
2001 |
OF |
Dominican College |
| Michael Perullo |
1999 |
1B |
Belmont Abbey College/Hofstra University |
| Bryan Anastasi |
1998 |
P |
Hofstra University |
| Joe Maione |
1997 |
IF |
St. Andrew's College |
| Dennis Tranchina |
1997 |
C |
Manhattan College (1997 NSCHSAA Player of the Year) |
